Watercolor painting of a rural landscape with trees, houses, and greenery, featuring a pond or water body in the foreground.

Consign with Confidence

For nearly 40 years, estates and collectors have trusted Butterscotch to bring their items to market and achieve the strongest possible results.

A close-up of a diamond engagement ring with a large central diamond and smaller diamonds on the band.
Two yellow and green ceramic bowls with decorative patterns, reflected on a glossy surface.

Why Sell with Butterscotch?

Consigning with Butterscotch delivers a number of benefits:

  • Global Reach: Your items are seen by hundreds of thousands of active bidders worldwide through LiveAuctioneers, Invaluable, and our in-house bidding platform.

  • Specialist Expertise: Our team draws on decades of knowledge to provide accurate identification and valuation.

  • Comprehensive Marketing: Every item receives professional photography, cataloging, and placement in our fully illustrated online catalog. Select highlights may also be featured in email marketing campaigns, on our website, and in print and digital advertising.

  • Transparent Commission Rates: Our only fee is our commission, which is determined by the size and quality of the collection. There are no additional costs or hidden fees.

  • Personalized Service: From complimentary in-home consultations and free estimates to professional pickup and secure storage, our team handles the details so you don’t have to.

  • Proven Results: We have achieved record-setting prices across multiple categories and consistently rank among the top-rated auctions on leading global platforms.

Our Commitment

At Butterscotch, our consignors are more than clients—they’re partners. Unlike larger houses, we pair global visibility with boutique-level attention, keeping you informed every step of the way and ensuring your collection receives the attention and respect it deserves.

Antique wooden chest of drawers with ornate brass hardware and curved legs.

Get Started

Whether you’re ready to consign or still have questions, our team is here to help.