Upcoming Auction: July 27


Already Consigned:

  • A fine collection of American Still Life paintings (20+ lots);

  • An important collection of historic Maps & Atlases (50+ lots);

  • Important Americana from a South Salem, NY collector;

  • Fine and Decorative Arts, Various owners

  • And more!

Consignment Deadline: June 27


Previous Auction:


Premiere Estate Collections

March 23, 2025


Buying at Butterscotch Auction Gallery

Butterscotch Auction presents three large, well-curated estate auctions each year.  Having been in business for over three decades, the gallery has developed a reputation for finding hidden treasures and presenting a wide variety of material.  Each auction is unique, so be sure to stay in touch by joining our email list.



Our Services

About Butterscotch Auction Gallery

As well as conducting auctions, Butterscotch Auction offers extensive appraisal services, primarily for Estate tax liability and Estate planning purposes, though we also appraise single items for Insurance and informational purposes. All appraisals are USPAP-compliant and our appraisers have expertise in a myriad of areas.

Founded in 1987 by fine art appraiser Paul D. Marinucci, Butterscotch Auctioneers & Appraisers has established itself as one of the preeminent estate auction houses in the greater New York City area.  It is the oldest and foremost auction of Westchester County, NY, and has developed a reputation for great serviceability and high-quality merchandise among consignors and buyers alike.